JAPAN TRIP ZERO

Home/Transport/Airports

TRANSPORT

Narita vs Haneda vs Kansai: which airport lands you closest to your hotel

Platform of the Tokyo Monorail at Haneda Airport Terminal 3 station
Haneda's Terminal 3 monorail platform: 13-20 minutes from a Tokyo hotel district.

Source: Wikimedia Commons · MaedaAkihiko, CC0

The airport question is really a hotel question. Narita is close to nothing; Haneda is 11 minutes from Shinagawa; Kansai is the one airport in Japan where the answer is simply “take the train, it is direct to Kyoto”. Book the airport your hotel can reach, not the one with the nicer terminal.

In one line Haneda for Tokyo — 11–20 minutes and about ¥330–520 to the city. Narita only if the fare is a lot cheaper or you are staying near Ueno or Nippori. Kansai for Osaka, Kyoto, Nara and Kobe, where it is not a compromise but the actual gateway.

1The numbers, not the marketing

AirportDistanceFastest optionTimeFare (one way)
Haneda → Shinagawa14 kmKeikyu Airport Line, direct11 min¥327 by IC card
Haneda → Hamamatsucho14 kmTokyo Monorail13–20 min¥520
Haneda → Asakusa20 kmKeikyu through train onto the Toei Asakusa line32 min¥599
Narita → Nippori / Ueno60 kmKeisei Skyliner36–41 min¥2,580
Narita → Tokyo Station60 kmJR Narita Express (N'EX)53 min¥3,140 (round-trip ticket ¥5,200)
Narita → Tokyo Station60 kmTYO-NRT airport bus65–90 min¥1,500
Narita → Tokyo Station60 kmAirport Limousine busTraffic dependent¥3,100
Kansai → Namba (Osaka)50 kmNankai Rapi:t, all reserved34–38 min¥1,490 (¥970 fare + ¥520 express)
Kansai → Namba (Osaka)50 kmNankai Airport Express~45 min¥970
Kansai → Osaka / Umeda50 kmAirport limousine bus~60 min¥1,800
Kansai → Kyoto75 kmJR Haruka, direct~76 min¥3,640 reserved — or ¥2,200 with the visitor one-way ticket

Read that table twice, because the marketing does not. Narita’s “36 minutes” is the Skyliner at its fastest, to Ueno, before you have found your platform. Narita’s 53 minutes is the N’EX to Tokyo Station — add another 20–30 minutes and a transfer if you are sleeping in Shinjuku or Shibuya. From Haneda, the same city is reached in 11 to 30 minutes with no luggage wrestling.

2Match the airport to the bed

This is the part that decides your booking.

  • Shinagawa, Shimbashi, Ginza, Tokyo Station: Haneda, no hesitation. Keikyu reaches Shinagawa in 11 minutes for ¥327, and Tokyo Station is 20 minutes away on the same fare table.
  • Shinjuku or Shibuya: still Haneda. Keikyu plus one JR hop is around 30 minutes and about ¥535, against 75–80 minutes and ¥3,330 on the N’EX from Narita.
  • Ueno, Asakusa or Nippori: Narita is genuinely competitive. The Skyliner is 36–41 minutes to Ueno with no transfer, and from Haneda a Keikyu through train runs straight onto the Asakusa line for 32 minutes and ¥599. Take whichever flight is cheaper — this is the one part of Tokyo where Narita wins on convenience, not just price.
  • Kyoto: fly into Kansai and take the Haruka. It is direct, about 76 minutes, and ¥2,200 for a visitor one-way ticket with a reserved seat. The alternative is landing in Tokyo and paying ¥14,720 and 2 hours 21 minutes on a Nozomi Shinkansen just to reach Kyoto.
  • Osaka (Namba, Umeda, Tennoji): Kansai, always. Rapi:t to Namba in 34 minutes, the bus to Umeda in about an hour, or the JR rapid to Osaka Station in roughly 70 minutes for ¥1,180.
  • Nara or Kobe: Kansai, with a direct discounted ticket for both.
The railway station concourse at Kansai International Airport, with JR West and Nankai signage
Kansai Airport station: JR West to the left, Nankai to the right, and both go straight into the city.

Source: Wikimedia Commons · CC0, no credit required

3The traps

  • Landing at one airport and flying out of the other. It is often the cheapest itinerary, and it costs you a half-day: Haneda to Narita is about 92 minutes and ¥1,783 by train. Fine if you have the time, painful on a four-day trip.
  • “Osaka” is two airports. Itami (ITM) is domestic-only. An itinerary that says Osaka with a cheap connection may be dropping you at a domestic field with no international check-in, an hour from Kansai.
  • Budget buses are traffic-dependent. The ¥1,500 bus to Tokyo Station is the best value at 07:00 and a 100-minute crawl at 18:00. The trains do not sit in traffic.
  • Late arrivals. Haneda runs later than most people expect — the last Keikyu train leaves around midnight — but Narita’s trains and the Skyliner stop well before that. Check the last departure for your line before you book a 21:00 landing and assume you will sleep at the airport.
The trap Never compare airports by their headline train time. Compare the total to your hotel door: walk to the platform, the ride, the transfer, the walk from the station. On that measure Narita is usually 75–100 minutes, not 36.
Departure hall at Narita Airport with check-in counters and flight boards
Narita: fine airport, awkward geography. 60 km and a ticket that costs more than a Tokyo hotel breakfast.

Source: Wikimedia Commons · CC0, no credit required

4What I would book

  • Tokyo, four nights, no strong fare difference: Haneda. Losing an hour each way to Narita on a short trip is not worth saving ¥2,000 on the ticket.
  • Narita is ¥150+ cheaper return, or you are staying in Ueno/Asakusa: take Narita and the Skyliner.
  • Kyoto, Osaka, Nara or Kobe: Kansai, and buy the Haruka one-way ticket for Kyoto or the Rapi:t for Namba before you fly — both are cheaper as visitor tickets than at the counter.
  • Travelling between Tokyo and Kansai in one trip: fly into Haneda or Narita and out of Kansai (or the reverse). The Nozomi Shinkansen between them is 2 hours 21 minutes and ¥14,720, so do not plan to bounce back and forth.

Keep reading

Sources

  • Keisei Electric Railway — Skyliner fares and travel times to Nippori and Ueno
  • JR East — N’EX fares, travel times and the N’EX TOKYO round-trip ticket
  • Keikyu / Haneda Airport Access Guide — fares and times to Shinagawa, Tokyo, Asakusa and Shinjuku
  • Tokyo Monorail — published fare table
  • Nankai Electric Railway — Rapi:t and Airport Express times and fares
  • JR West — HARUKA one-way ticket prices to Osaka, Shin-Osaka, Kyoto, Kobe and Nara
  • Airport Limousine and TYO-NRT — bus fares on the Narita and Kansai routes

← Back to Japan Trip Zero